...with a slightly-lingual-in-two-languages toddler(is there a word for that?)
Paula (at shelves, arms stretching up to show need for something out of reach): Apuka! [Dad] Puzzle!
Me: You want me to get you a puzzle?
Paula (nodding furiously): Igen! [Yes]
Me: Would you like the big puzzle or the small puzzle?
Paula: Igen!
Me (patiently): The big one or the small one?
Paula (still nodding furiously): Igen! Igen!
Me: Would you like the b-i-g puzzle or the s-m-a-l-l puzzle?
Paula: Igen!
(pause, light of understanding begins to dawn in her eyes, looks at me, and says very slowly and deliberately, as if to an idiot) Yes.
Posts
Top FPL Podcasts to Follow in 2025/26
2 weeks ago
4 comments:
:-)
In terms of first-order predicate logic, Paula is probably correct. If she wants one of the puzzles – either the big one (b) or small one (s) - then her reply "yes" (or, indeed "igen") represents the truth value in all circumstances:
( paulawants(b) ∨ paulawants(s) )
The truth value of this will also be fulfilled if she wanted both puzzles, as, indeed, any acquisitive toddler might. However, if your request presupposes exclusive disjunction:
( paulawants(b) p ⊕ q paulawants(s) )
her reply will not represent the truth value if she wanted both puzzles. This is a failure of language than of logic. If the Hungarian language has a separate words for “or” and “exclusive or”, which would help a lot!
;-)
:)))
i love the "slightly-lingual-in-two-languages" definition.
i've taught marta (who turns 2 today) the difference between big and small by pointing first at my own nose - mama's nose bolshoi (in low-pitched voice, BAALSHOOOOI) - and then at hers - marta's nose malenkiy (high-pitched, maaaaalenkiiiy).
i've recently started recording her voice - on my cell phone, mainly - interviewing her - that's what my father did when i was a kid - and i really love listening to those recordings and hope it'll be as fun for marta when she grows up.
paula is turning 2 sometime soon, isn't she?
best of luck to you and your family!
Hmmm...sounds to me like she's just keeping the ways of women a mystery, as is her duty...even at her age! :) Way to go, Paula!
gd: When she can talk properly I'm sure that she'll explain her logic in exactly that way. :-)
veronica: thanks. Yes, Paula will be 2 in three weeks. Every day a new word, every day a new trauma ;-)
Thanks Julie. I didn't know you had a blog! The things one discovers.
Post a Comment